| Rev. Debbie Roe | 2008 |
| Rev. Karen Meiers | June 2003 - 2008 |
| Rev. Tom Wade (interim) | Jan. 2003 |
| Rev. Art Clippinger (interim) | Dec. 2002 |
| Rev. Nelson Scott (interim) | Jan. 1999-Nov. 2002 |
| Rev. Lori Keller | Aug. 1994-Dec. 1998 |
| Rev. Larry Miller (interim) | May 1994-Aug. 1994 |
| Rev. Patricia Preuz Connor (interim) | July 1993-May 1994 |
| Rev. Milton Sumerel | 1983-1993 |
| Rev. Robert Tormohlen | June 1, 1983-Oct 1983 |
| Rev. James Smelley | 1979-1983 |
| Rev. Roger J. Peterson | 1958-1979 |
| Rev. Louis Schnuck | 1931-1958 |
| Rev. Max Schultz | 1923-1930 |
| Rev. E. Roglin | March 4, 1923-Aug 1923 |
| Rev. F. A. Stoelting | 1914-1923 |
| Rev. H.J. Schoettle | 1911-1914 |
| Rev. Thomas Haller | 1908-1911 |
| Rev. J. Neuman | 1905-1908 |
| Rev. Karl Roth | 1903-1905 |
| Rev. A. Merkle | 1898-1903 |
| Rev. H. Juergens | 1889-1898 |
| Rev. Val Ziemer | 1881-1889 |
| Rev. H. Ludwig | 1880-1881 |
| Rev. M. Mehl | 1877-1880 |
| Rev. Phillip Karbach | 1860-1864 |
| Rev. J.F. Schlundt | 1856-1860 and 1864-1877 |
| Rev. Carl Schaller | until 1856 |
| Rev. Settlemeyer |